Young America's Foundation

Join Our Email List

  • New Guard Inner
  • Penn State Professor Links Voter ID Laws to KKK (Update)

    1/17/2013 3:33:41 PM Posted by Patrick Coyle

    Angry ProfessorBy Brendan Pringle

    Penn State senior and YAF activist Victor Schleich says he was taken off guard in his film studies class when Professor Matt Jordan’s lesson on “The Birth of a Nation” abruptly shifted focus.

    After showing excerpts from the controversial film about the Ku Klux Klan, Professor Jordan ended the class with a montage of news clips criticizing voter ID laws.
    Disturbed by the possibility that his professor was trying to equate voter ID laws with the actions of the KKK, Victor complained to him in an email:
    On Jan 10, 2013, at 2:59 PM, Victor Schleich wrote:
    There was something at the end of class today that greatly concerned me. Towards the end of class we were going over the film THE BIRTH OF A NATION. The final shot we saw was a scene where a number of the KKK members were scaring black men back into their homes signifying voter suppression. I had no problem displaying that scene with the proper context that it was incredibly racist and that the content was unacceptable. However, as class was ending there was footage on the screen of news coverage concerning the issue of voter ID laws and commentary suggesting that these laws were new minority voter suppression. John Stewart even made references that these were the new horsemen of intimidation when it came to minorities voting. Now, in the context of the film we had discussed I can't help but see this display as an attempt to equate a voter ID law to actions taken by the KKK. If this was the intention of that footage then this is is incredibly offensive. However, I hope this is simply a misunderstanding.

    Rather than acknowledge the Schleich’s concern about the offensive nature of the course material, the professor wrote the following belittling defense:

    On Jan 10, 2013, at 3:12 PM, Matt Jordan wrote:

    I was - indeed - trying to elicit moral comparisons with this juxtaposition, given that the KKK was behind voter suppression in the 1880s and 1920s, by splicing that clip in there. I am sorry that you find that offensive, but I find disenfranchizing [sic] minority and elderly voters based on specious arguments about voter fraud (which multiple studies have shown to be trumped up and, indeed, many of the architects of these laws have all but admitted were purely designed to suppress the vote) equally offensive in a country predicated on one person, one vote.
    I don't think I equated them, but I certainly want you all to think about it. I am sorry that you find this work of challenging you all to think offensive.

    Matt Jordan
    Associate Professor
    Dept. of Film/Video and Media Studies
    College of Communications
    Penn State University

    Professor Jordan openly admits to making moral comparisons between the KKK and the conservative voices behind voter ID laws, and scolds Schleich for daring to voice his concern.
    Unfortunately for Professor Jordan, arguments about voter fraud are far from “specious”. As many may recall back in April of 2012, Project Veritas journalist James O’Keefe refuted Attorney General Eric Holder’s dismissive statements about voter fraud by showing how easy it was to obtain Holder’s own election ballot at the polls.
    Moreover, there is no valid proof that any current voter ID laws were “purely designed to suppress the vote.”
    According to Penn State’s website, COMM 150 Intro to Film Studies is supposed to examine attitudes and assumptions about film as well as “the role cinema--and, especially, narrative film--plays in relating individuals to the values and assumptions of their culture”.
    What “assumptions” was Professor Jordan precisely trying to demonstrate by bringing up the issue of voter ID laws? Was he equating these laws to racism and painting their conservative sponsors as racist?
    Young America’s Foundation commends Schleich for having the courage to challenge his professor and stand up for the truth.

    (UPDATE) has picked up the story which you can read here.

    Brendan Pringle is a Development Officer at Young America's Foundation's Reagan Ranch Center. 


    • Readers' Comments

    • Unfortunately, I fear there is more of this liberal indoctrination to come from this professor. However, there is no where for the left to hide anymore even on the college campus. Thanks to the great resources here at YAF I was able to work with people to get this story out.
      Posted by Victor Schleich on 01/18/2013
    • So Victor Schleich apparently thinks that physical intimidation was the only method used by the KKK to suppress minority voting rights? It sounds to me like Mr. Scleich fell asleep in history class. If he had been paying attention, he might have learned something about how KKK politicians abandoned the Democratic Party in the "Solid South" with the passage of the 1964 Civil Rights Act. Now, almost fifty years later, those same methods of discrimination (both direct and indirect) are being repackaged and sold to an unwitting generation as "Voter ID Laws," blatant partisan gerrymandering, Jim Crow era "Right to Work" laws and the belligerantly ignorant Tea Party "Birther" movement. I truly feel sorry for members of the Young Americans for Freedom. You truly have no idea how you all have been duped.
      Posted by Willie Green on 01/23/2013
    • Penn State is above the Mason Dixon Line - right? Seems poor Victor ventured a bit too far north.
      Posted by B W Furness on 01/25/2013
    • And yet no one complains that Facebook will arbitrarily demand photo ID's from people to reinstate their accounts.
      Posted by Tyrone on 01/29/2013
    • Victor, I appreciate you sharing these emails so everyone can see the real Matt Jordan. He claims that he is a victim of the "Right-Wing Echo Chamber," however us students are victims of his anti-conservative rants and political propaganda. He clearly shows no respect for others' opinions, but what if we were to post an anti-liberal video in one of our response assignments as an example of a theme in the movie? I guarantee we would get nothing higher than a 0% for that assignment, and I'm afraid that his hostility will not stop at his blog and will show itself in your semester grade. Here's to hoping he is smart enough to not retaliate against you for voicing your opinion. That is, in fact, what he claims to be challenging us to do, right? He wants to "challenge us to think about these things in our culture?"
      Posted by Another COMM 150 Student on 02/02/2013
    • I\'m shocked that I found this info so eisaly.
      Posted by Forebes on 02/15/2013
    • GMFc7i <a href="">jfsvahvdxfau</a>
      Posted by dbvfsxhn on 02/16/2013
    • UhbkZ7 , [url=]iogyeuccpwfy[/url], [link=]ufmapguzwcvt[/link],
      Posted by gujnhxhot on 02/16/2013
    • X0EzT4 <a href="">pydjscltnzvq</a>
      Posted by jngnemor on 02/18/2013
    • EATiL0 <a href="">kjppmvpdgqoe</a>, [url=]cpjaneahpykw[/url], [link=]wdibatobtkfv[/link],
      Posted by 58862 on 06/01/2013
    • KCXP98 <a href="">dhijzoqbmfwi</a>, [url=]enyvvbzxakab[/url], [link=]bcwyhhkyfack[/link],
      Posted by npdplhkqygv on 07/15/2013
    • NR9old <a href="">mzvtjqgtocec</a>, [url=]lttilzfbpytj[/url], [link=]mxbetqqynoyu[/link],
      Posted by vwitof on 08/31/2013
    • i8CM4n Muchos Gracias for your post.Really looking forward to read more. Much obliged.
      Posted by 1151 on 09/13/2013
    • yKLrwQ I cannot thank you enough for the article. Will read on...
      Posted by 201695 on 09/24/2013
    • 64KUxr I truly appreciate this article post.Really looking forward to read more. Cool.
      Posted by 46420 on 10/16/2013
    • v2VV7T wow, awesome blog.Really thank you! Awesome.
      Posted by 920822 on 10/31/2013
    • laKtR3 Wow, great blog.Really looking forward to read more. Want more.
      Posted by 690245 on 11/18/2013
    • BaT6RC I truly appreciate this post.Thanks Again. Cool.
      Posted by 19852 on 12/14/2013
    • OsuUe8 Enjoyed every bit of your article. Really Cool.
      Posted by 85211 on 01/07/2014
    • tf0vRn Hey, thanks for the blog post.Much thanks again. Awesome.
      Posted by 93225 on 01/18/2014
    • gd4uST Thanks again for the article. Fantastic.
      Posted by 266479 on 02/28/2014
    • 9cdiTS I really liked your post. Want more.
      Posted by 57265 on 03/22/2014
    • pFCg76 Very neat blog article.Really thank you! Fantastic.
      Posted by 1622 on 04/01/2014
    • VSlQLe Thanks for sharing, this is a fantastic blog.Really thank you! Much obliged.
      Posted by 686673 on 04/20/2014
    • 3KslLA Thanks so much for the post.Much thanks again.
      Posted by 834451 on 05/11/2014
    • JM34oe Hey, thanks for the article.Really looking forward to read more. Will read on...
      Posted by 35833 on 06/04/2014
    • H02xaE Really informative blog post. Much obliged.
      Posted by 671624 on 06/19/2014
    • 64YsAt I am so grateful for your blog.Much thanks again. Fantastic.
      Posted by 1775 on 07/04/2014
    • Sn65C4 Awesome blog post.Much thanks again. Cool.
      Posted by 5736 on 07/18/2014
    • NOdVE7 Appreciate you sharing, great article post.Really looking forward to read more. Keep writing.
      Posted by 7570 on 08/01/2014
    • jZh1pP I really like and appreciate your article post.Really looking forward to read more. Much obliged.
      Posted by 796115 on 08/05/2014
    • CKixHG <a href="">ptmyqksykzro</a>, [url=]uyzumhwvhtgr[/url], [link=]swlmydwvbfmj[/link],
      Posted by dklsjui on 09/18/2014
    • n0uadE <a href="">baadqfjzhmtm</a>, [url=]tgrbkophebqe[/url], [link=]sijlmlvwlchv[/link],
      Posted by awtfdm on 09/19/2014
    Leave a comment
Copyright 2014 Young America's Foundation | 11480 Commerce Park Dr., Suite 600, Reston, VA 20191-1556 | Ph. 1.800.USA.1776 | Fax 703.318.9122 | |