Young America's Foundation

Join Our Email List

  • New Guard Inner
  • Intellectual bravery seems dead on the Left.

    Young America’s Foundation agreed to help a conservative group on Marquette University’s campus sponsor an abortion debate between a conservative and liberal professor.

    That is until the liberal professor bailed.

    The event’s organizer, Maggie Gervase, had booked Marquette’s Dr. Dan Maguire to represent the pro-abortion position and sent a follow-up email confirming the debate format. She got this in reply:

    Maggie, I just looked up [the pro-life professor] Dr. Mike Adams and found he is a psychology-criminology professor. I am a theologian presenting theological arguments. I would not try to debate Dr. Adams in psychology/criminology since it is not my field. Similarly he would not want to debate me in theology since he is not a theologians [sic] and could not argue a theological position with professional competence. We would be skew lines. So when you find a theologian who wants to debate me, as was done at Notre Dame, get back in touch. Dan Maguire.

    In response, the conservative professor, Dr. Mike Adams (University of North Carolina Wilmington), said this in a Townhall op-ed today:

    Professor Maguire’s excuse for backing out of his commitment to debate me is dishonest for at least two reasons:

    1.     He has previously made, in public, an argument for abortion that is not theological. Specifically, he argued that, even if human, the unborn is not a person, which means the unborn are not citizens deserving of equal protection. This is an argument based on the 14thAmendment. Clearly, he is stepping into the constitutional arena, despite his claims to remain safely on theological ground.

    2.     In the 1990s - at Marquette University, no less – Professor Maguire debated the issue of capital punishment. Unsurprisingly, he took the anti-death penalty side. Later, he was also featured on a Marquette panel arguing specifically in favor of government run-health care. In neither case did he debate a theological issue from a strictly theological position relying strictly upon his theological training.

    Dr. Adams clearly exposed Dr. Maguire’s inconsistency. He’s publically debated topics from a non-theological perspective, so why was this debate different?

    Another Marquette professor, Dr. John McAdams—who had previously debated Dr. Maguire—confirmed this inconsistency in a blog here:

    His insistence that he will debate only theologians is odd, given that we, over the last couple of decades, have been on two panels with Maguire. One, in the 1990s, was on the death penalty. Two people (us included) debated on the pro-death penalty side, and Maguire (along with another faculty member) were on the anti-death penalty side.

    Just a few years ago, we and Maguire were (with several other people) on a panel on health care. It was not explicitly a debate, but panelists were chosen based on opposing perspectives on government run-health care.

    Maguire has no special expertise in criminal justice nor in health care, but he was willing to appear.

    With his inconsistency and cowardice exposed, the only real question is: Will Dr. Marguire un-bail and agree to the debate?  

    • Readers' Comments

    • Are we sure this is not astro-turfing?Can we read the bill on-line yet? I really trust you and your info, EPA, but plasee say it ain't so.
      Posted by Ammy on 08/10/2013
    • .I ave oft times tried to explain to <a href="http://yhdlbmc.com">pepole</a> that my continuing search for excellence and the next peak have nothing to do with dissatisfaction with where I am. I think that life in general is a series of achievements, setbacks, growth, developing new strengths, perfecting the skills and talents you do have, and on and on. People often ask me when enough will be enough. I don't know that there is an answer to that. For someone like me or you that continue in search of greater summits, I don't know that there is a stopping point.That brings to mind a great quote that many will recognize; There is no way to happiness, Happiness is The Way . The BuddhaHappiness is many things to many different <a href="http://yhdlbmc.com">pepole</a> and we all express it in different ways. But living a life that challenges you more, that brings out a strong sense of mission being accomplished, and opens new doors at every turn, is indeed a state of Being Happy & in total alignment with self. When that happens, is when the magic takes place, and you serve so many others as well as your personal sense of self.
      Posted by Raju on 08/11/2013
    • Christina and Jay,I totally ejoyned the photo blog of Leigh and Stu's wedding photos. You two did a fabulous job of capturing the true beauty of our special couple and our gorgeous Grandson, Jamie. Thanks so much!I too, can hardly wait to see more of the photos yet to come.Adrienne (Mom and Grandma) http://qzjtidl.com [url=http://skvzfndfry.com]skvzfndfry[/url] [link=http://vsnfnkhi.com]vsnfnkhi[/link]
      Posted by Israelfraga on 08/12/2013
    • Fantastic pictures! Every one was <a href="http://sjczvjx.com">sipmly</a> stunning. I agree the pictures capture how special and unique of a day it was. Congrats to the happy couple and well done to the photographers.
      Posted by Billy on 08/14/2013
    • Ive seen this great australian band from when they stretad with Bon Scott twice and every tour since then with both Razors Edge & both Black Ic... http://tlngfbhmp.com [url=http://xhxgegj.com]xhxgegj[/url] [link=http://mnvkkzqwa.com]mnvkkzqwa[/link]
      Posted by Joaquim on 08/30/2013
    • ggujFb Hey, thanks for the blog post.Much thanks again.
      Posted by 887592 on 09/05/2013
    • uHVer1 Appreciate you sharing, great article.Thanks Again. Want more.
      Posted by 5510 on 09/13/2013
    • KwCu8k Appreciate you sharing, great article.Much thanks again. Will read on...
      Posted by 74137 on 09/24/2013
    • 47ROkg Thanks for the article.Much thanks again. Will read on...
      Posted by 1823 on 10/15/2013
    • BWUchb Say, you got a nice article post.Much thanks again. Really Cool.
      Posted by 9895 on 10/23/2013
    • PLwAvt Thanks-a-mundo for the article. Much obliged.
      Posted by 9218 on 12/15/2013
    • 4A5HIM Thanks for the blog article. Awesome.
      Posted by 889488 on 01/18/2014
    • p7IzFm Thanks a lot for the article.Much thanks again. Awesome.
      Posted by 72236 on 01/31/2014
    • jZ7Ybe Thanks for the blog.Thanks Again. Keep writing.
      Posted by 8118 on 02/28/2014
    • 8hmiG5 I really liked your article. Great.
      Posted by 57034 on 03/22/2014
    • 8Y65qk Thanks again for the post.Much thanks again.
      Posted by 4978 on 04/01/2014
    Leave a comment
    Name
    Email
    Comment
Copyright 2013 Young America's Foundation | 110 Elden Street, Herndon, VA 20170 | Ph. 1.800.USA.1776 | Fax 703.318.9122
www.yaf.org | www.reaganranch.org | www.nationaljournalismcenter.org