Young America's Foundation

Join Our Email List

  • New Guard Inner
  • Students Want ROTC, Administrators Sit on Their Hands

    4/13/2011 2:50:22 PM Posted by Patrick Coyle

    YAF ColumbiaBy Jiesi Zhao

    For nine long months, Stanford has barely made any headway on figuring out whether ROTC has a place on campus - until this week. Maybe. 

    In a referendum vote, as part of this year’s student government elections, Stanford undergrads expressed their support of establishing ROTC back on campus. However, when we break down the votes, it becomes clear that administrators could potentially interpret the results in various ways.  

    Specifically, students were asked to select from the following options (I have also included the percentage and number of students who voted for each option):

    • I support the return of ROTC to Stanford University – 44.1 percent (2406 votes)
    • I oppose the return of ROTC to Stanford University – 17 percent (929)
    • I choose to abstain – 38.8 percent (2117)

    Meanwhile, Brown University has also come out with voting results on the return of ROTC this week, and the numbers are similar to Stanford’s. In particular, it is clear that the number of students at Brown who disapprove of ROTC’s return are in the minority, with only 9.7% who strongly disapprove and 14% who somewhat disapprove. Moreover, around 43% of students support the return of ROTC’s presence on campus and the remaining 33% were “not familiar enough with the issue” or had “no opinion”. 

    While the good news is that clearly the number of students who are adamantly against the return of ROTC are in the minority, I have to wonder what choices like “I choose to abstain” really means; and more importantly, how administrators are going to treat the abstain and “not familiar enough with the issue” positions as they continue to weigh the arguments on both sides.

    I hope that administrators take the votes at face value and recognize that the large majority of students want ROTC on campus. The fact is, in both cases, the votes pan out in favor of the reinstitution.

    Jiesi Zhao is a Sarah T. Hermann Intern Scholar at Young America's Foundation

    • Readers' Comments

    • We are living in a railpdy changing world today. Many of the old taboos that once existed in our society have become so extinct that for many it seems impossible that they actually existed at all. And this should be a comforting fact to you because of your children.The road will be tough emotionally and mentally because, like everyone else, you do not see the future, yet you're constantly facing it. And though the future may seem bleak at times, especially when the going gets tough, it is always easier to find your way through darkness when you have your head held high and looking straight ahead.And think for a second how much society will have changed by the time your kids are cognizant of the effects of reality and decisions. Do no doubt it, not for one second. Your kids will be raised in the brightest and most accepting generation that our world has ever seen. They will not see you as gay, or as the man who left their mom, no. They will see their father, their dad, and a strong one at that. It takes courage to do what you did, considering your situation, but you did it and you didn't back away. But to be the father and the man that the future holds, you have to not give up. You have to keep your head held high. You have to be there when the times calls, and even when it doesn't. Through your struggles of self acceptance and the choices you have made, you have been given a golden opportunity to shine through the shadows that you're facing. You have the ability to come out on top, above and beyond, and to show that what you did was not a mistake. Because in life there are no mistakes, there are only choices and what you do when you're given those choices.If you could only see what I see, then you would see. Though, probably not now, or tomorrow, next week, or even next year, but in time you will see. And when you do see, it will be a beautiful sight. You will be standing on the summit on the biggest mountain you may ever climb, and from your vantage you will be able to see the clouds that once obscured your path. You will see the people you met throughout your climb to the top, including your children, and they will be there with you when you reach the top. The air will be clean, and the burdens relieved. You may have a few scars left from your journey, but they will not compare to the prize that awaits at the summit.So please, do not give up. We're all down at the bottom of the mountain watching, hoping, and rooting for you. And though our shouts and calls may be faint at times, know that they carry with them all the love and support that we can muster. Remember that the best paths in life are always the most difficult. But also remember that the most difficult tasks reap the greatest rewards.You have all of my love and all of my support. I will think about you tonight, and tomorrow. I will think about you next week and next month. I will always be thinking, and I will always be hoping. Love,Caleb
      Posted by Richard on 09/18/2012
    • aEvJUa <a href="">zqybmjctqwit</a>
      Posted by uszveabg on 09/18/2012
    • UlT4kT , [url=]mljdpnsgsdsx[/url], [link=]nsyygefroiwl[/link],
      Posted by sbgqjpde on 09/19/2012
    • RuJYX0 <a href="">bhybnuxfqefx</a>
      Posted by unsqjfmlser on 09/20/2012
    • Xdlh3Z , [url=]smckqltbrjtf[/url], [link=]uhsnqorcyiod[/link],
      Posted by nbryjyuzzf on 09/21/2012
    • Hqic6O
      Posted by 90145 on 08/09/2015
    Leave a comment
Copyright 2015 Young America's Foundation | 11480 Commerce Park Dr., Suite 600, Reston, VA 20191-1556 | Ph. 1.800.USA.1776 | Fax 703.318.9122 | |