Young America's Foundation

Join Our Email List

  • New Guard Inner
  • schutteBy Samantha Schutte, Former YAF Intern and Foundation Activist

    It wouldn’t be college if kids weren’t whining about something.  When it isn’t dining hall food, 8 a.m. classes, and pepper spray incidents, it’s money.  For students of the ten University of California campuses, state funding has seen significant cuts and tuition is on the rise.  Tuition hikes are obviously unpopular among students, with most seeing the solution as increased state funding. 

    The University of California Student Association states that tuition is skyrocketing because “California does not have enough money because it is not taking in enough revenue.  Corporations are not paying their fair share.”  The State of California certainly does have a budget problem, but I believe it is the result of excessive spending, not insufficient revenue.

    fixUCA Redistributionist Proposal

    Recently, students from the UC Riverside group, Fix UC, came out with a unique idea to eliminate financial burdens on students.  The basic premise of the “UC Student Investment Proposal” is that students would no longer pay any tuition up front, but rather commit to contributing 5% of their post-graduation income for 20 years.  The architects of this plan claim that it would triple the revenue of the UC system in 20 years.

    The proposal states that transfer students would pay 1% less, while out of state and international students would pay 1% more.  There would be a .5% incentive to stay and work in California and a 1% incentive to work in the public sector.  Students would also have the option to include on-campus housing costs.

    UC = University of Collections

    Paying tuition up front would not even be an option in this proposal, so schools would have to trust all graduates to pay back into the system upon completion of their education.  Given UC enrollment, it would take massive oversight to ensure that so many graduating classes of students were paying at all, let alone paying the right amount.  This plan would turn the UC system into a massive collections agency. 

    Much like with our current tax system, many high-income graduates would likely attempt to find ways to report lower earnings to reduce payments.  Low-income graduates who have little disposable income after meeting basic living expenses may fail to make payments altogether.  Unemployed graduates would be allowed to skip payments, which means that the UC would have to absorb lost revenue, all while the government provides welfare benefits.

    The harder you work, the more you pay

    This plan does not distinguish between students who take three, four, five, or more years to graduate.  A student who chooses to dilly dally, fails classes, or takes a light course load and finishes in five years faces no penalty, even though their cost of education would be considerably higher.  A student who works hard to complete their degree in three years would start paying 5% of their income immediately upon employment, despite entering the workforce sooner and costing the university less.  With money being no object, many students would choose to take their time, party more, and coast through their college years.

    If a student were to drop out of a UC, they would be expected to pay the annual tuition rate for the time spent in the system.  This is clearly an unrealistic expectation.  Someone who dropped out did so for a reason and is highly unlikely to have the means to pay tens of thousands of dollars for an education they did not finish.  Requiring students to invest in their own education by paying tuition up front is more likely to attract motivated individuals who will go on to make something of themselves.

    Perhaps the most reasonable condition of the UC Student Investment Proposal is that students who die while attending a UC would not be expected to contribute any money; however, that leaves the schools to absorb the costs incurred during the time they did attend school.

    Lucrative Majors vs. Liberal Majors

    Engineering, science, math, and technology majors achieve median earnings of more than twice those of many liberal arts and humanities majors.  Over the course of this 20-year, 5% payment plan, this means that a chemical engineer is likely to pay at least twice as much as someone who majored in women’s studies. 

    This provides an incentive for the UC system to push students into programs that lead to higher paying jobs, as a higher salary for a graduate translates into more revenue for the UC system.  The proposal even addresses this important fact, stating that “Campuses will be encouraged to refrain from giving preferential treatment to departments and majors that lead students to more traditionally lucrative careers."

    At current rates, four years of UC tuition would amount to just under $50,000.  Under the new proposal, someone who makes anything more than $50,000 on average over their first 20 years in the workforce would pay more than they would with today’s tuition system.  Liberal arts and humanities majors may benefit slightly.  Engineering, science, and math majors will pay more for choosing lucrative career fields.

    Fixed? Nope.

    There are countless other holes in this ridiculous proposal.  These kids need to take a course in basic economics.  If this is the best that a UC student can come up with, then we have bigger problems than a budget shortfall.

    If this proposal were implemented, University of California graduates would be in a real fix, alright.  Punishing success is no way to build a prosperous society.

    Samantha Schutte is a former Sarah T. Hermann Intern Scholar at Young America’s Foundation and a conservative activist at UCLA.  

    • Readers' Comments

    • It depends.Public uiiversnties do not offer financial aid to international students so while they're cheaper in real dollars, they may be harder to reach.Private schools are more expensive, but no, they do NOT tend to have different tuition costs for domestic vs international students. Moreover, they can offer financial aid (grants, loans).Private religious schools tend to be less expensive (although this is not always the case).To give you specific figures, at top private schools (college uiiversnties) the cost can be as high as $35,000/year. Was this answer helpful?
      Posted by Pegkoop on 08/06/2012
    • q8nLUC <a href="">ymrkqzfetbtv</a>
      Posted by qqdsheb on 08/06/2012
    • UcUrjx , [url=]akrspdfvgkxq[/url], [link=]anrvnqfdkpgr[/link],
      Posted by txekgqpbpwh on 08/07/2012
    • 4Olm9k <a href="">dbmgyplbzydm</a>
      Posted by ossvouqyxos on 08/07/2012
    • eOZL7T , [url=]bqwrcysurysh[/url], [link=]lhwvnugxrcgj[/link],
      Posted by qjzbcfdm on 08/08/2012
    • B0PSpf <a href="">xsqrixhtxhtf</a>, [url=]yjasdxxgocjh[/url], [link=]suctggucxdep[/link],
      Posted by quvxlofv on 08/18/2012
    • B0PSpf <a href="">xsqrixhtxhtf</a>, [url=]yjasdxxgocjh[/url], [link=]suctggucxdep[/link],
      Posted by quvxlofv on 08/18/2012
    • fbojB1 <a href="">rbmllwroltvz</a>, [url=]kxulgxcigzxu[/url], [link=]xjynstueyowl[/link],
      Posted by jujwre on 10/03/2012
    • It's spokoy how clever some ppl are. Thanks!
      Posted by Rogelma on 12/28/2012
    • o6CkKa <a href="">tndgfcvhvlfm</a>
      Posted by ewutssgqsx on 12/29/2012
    • Cf9MVN , [url=]afxdbizbohmh[/url], [link=]xbjlwjmrgsoz[/link],
      Posted by gltpncz on 01/01/2013
    • Z4B7iM
      Posted by 261378 on 04/28/2013
    • 5aggHl I am so grateful for your post.Thanks Again.
      Posted by 644821 on 09/06/2013
    • Ly3AWJ I appreciate you sharing this blog article.Really thank you! Cool.
      Posted by 3676 on 09/13/2013
    • p5F0bd Great, thanks for sharing this blog post.Really thank you! Really Cool.
      Posted by 429352 on 10/16/2013
    • yWXvkb Thanks a lot for the blog post.Really looking forward to read more. Will read on...
      Posted by 4789 on 10/24/2013
    • PA73hO Really informative blog article.Thanks Again.
      Posted by 519212 on 11/19/2013
    • WHhcAN Fantastic post.Really thank you! Awesome.
      Posted by 8636 on 12/15/2013
    • 11huG0 <a href="">czukalnqjbkc</a>, [url=]ecumkbbramdz[/url], [link=]rlplwdpliowy[/link],
      Posted by 55874 on 12/25/2013
    • <a href="">cialis precio</a>
      Posted by 61795 on 01/04/2014
    • <a href="">comprar levitra generico</a>
      Posted by 109932 on 01/05/2014
    • <a href="">kamagra online</a>
      Posted by 55753 on 01/06/2014
    • <a href="">comprar kamagra oral jelly 100mg</a>
      Posted by 343839 on 01/07/2014
    • <a href="">apcalis oral jelly buy</a>
      Posted by 670924 on 01/09/2014
    • <a href="">caverta online</a>
      Posted by 40402 on 01/09/2014
    • <a href="">caverta online</a>
      Posted by 40402 on 01/09/2014
    • <a href="">cialis and bph</a>
      Posted by 246507 on 01/09/2014
    • <a href="">cialis soft tabs online</a>
      Posted by 8782 on 01/09/2014
    • <a href="">eriacta sildenafil citrate</a>
      Posted by 708924 on 01/09/2014
    • <a href="">tadalis sx india</a>
      Posted by 76703 on 01/09/2014
    • <a href="">kamagra legal in usa</a>
      Posted by 139396 on 01/09/2014
    • <a href="">kamagra oral jelly for women</a>
      Posted by 56091 on 01/09/2014
    • <a href="">levitra what is it</a>
      Posted by 735630 on 01/10/2014
    • <a href="">female viagra use</a>
      Posted by 5140 on 01/10/2014
    • <a href="">silagra dosage</a>
      Posted by 2150 on 01/10/2014
    • <a href="">viagra super active 100mg</a>
      Posted by 86028 on 01/10/2014
    • <a href="">tadacip</a>
      Posted by 521757 on 01/10/2014
    • <a href="">cialis super active</a>
      Posted by 19858 on 01/10/2014
    • <a href="">trial packs viagra</a>
      Posted by 519820 on 01/10/2014
    • <a href="">viagra young</a>
      Posted by 88922 on 01/10/2014
    • <a href="">viagra soft tablets</a>
      Posted by 3498 on 01/10/2014
    • <a href="">levitra soft</a>
      Posted by 33155 on 01/10/2014
    • <a href="">levitra oral jelly</a>
      Posted by 344006 on 01/10/2014
    • <a href="">generic levitra super force</a>
      Posted by 8694 on 01/10/2014
    • <a href="">levitra professional generic</a>
      Posted by 3005 on 01/11/2014
    • ZjZd1D A round of applause for your article.Much thanks again. Really Great.
      Posted by 363759 on 01/16/2014
    • comment5, <a href=""></a>, [url=][/url], =PP,
      Posted by Kuhyngkk on 01/21/2014
    • greg.txt;1;3
      Posted by PUqXAsagfahZJhnuJ on 01/28/2014
    • rgW6es <a href="">whfiushvnasq</a>, [url=]exckbzunessl[/url], [link=]vzdcawadzrbj[/link],
      Posted by skdnwtnjduj on 01/28/2014
    • , <a href="">binary options brokers</a>, [url=""]binary options brokers[/url], >:]]],
      Posted by Hjczaxst on 02/03/2014
    • ex4Ruf <a href="">kpvuivngqmsf</a>, [url=]qymwgybfxyaj[/url], [link=]vtdnjbnvtpwh[/link],
      Posted by buizqup on 02/08/2014
    • ctEdzN <a href="">yjavuifoslgp</a>, [url=]yrivkydvetmt[/url], [link=]bvxdpxlgzfuf[/link],
      Posted by mlmxcye on 02/09/2014
    • rwloYh <a href="">gzrcfwlmjqjv</a>, [url=]rgdkqvwsqlmp[/url], [link=]rxwqmisiimsz[/link],
      Posted by zvcvzrorus on 02/10/2014
    • 9y1Tbz <a href="">fnydapuszsgm</a>, [url=]ekspslcfzyqd[/url], [link=]dlywudzjqykr[/link],
      Posted by wsokqlkw on 02/18/2014
    • DVYv7A A round of applause for your blog post.Really looking forward to read more. Will read on...
      Posted by 60413 on 02/28/2014
    • MRQrzX
      Posted by 25996 on 03/05/2014
    • 3nEmek <a href="">myflquxmoivz</a>, [url=]qmjxtyeyzzhh[/url], [link=]qnlxokzactwn[/link],
      Posted by ulfmcvrwu on 03/06/2014
    • QBq9r0 Enjoyed every bit of your blog article.Much thanks again. Want more.
      Posted by 7908 on 03/22/2014
    • uWFHZw <a href="">iwnbbebwklio</a>, [url=]vdrwaqraigja[/url], [link=]rlquqwfxxals[/link],
      Posted by zpjomzuscn on 03/24/2014
    • fE1DiQ Major thankies for the post.Really looking forward to read more. Awesome.
      Posted by 2715 on 04/01/2014
    • 6edPei <a href="">zulurcrcwbxb</a>, [url=]vbcjyirzvxnq[/url], [link=]driciwurrvqu[/link],
      Posted by nntkarcmhih on 04/05/2014
    • OTutAx
      Posted by 10258 on 04/08/2014
    • fmewIb Great, thanks for sharing this post.Really looking forward to read more. Great.
      Posted by 9776 on 04/17/2014
    Leave a comment
Copyright 2013 Young America's Foundation | 110 Elden Street, Herndon, VA 20170 | Ph. 1.800.USA.1776 | Fax 703.318.9122 | |