Young America's Foundation

Join Our Email List

  • New Guard Inner
  • Wealth and Justice: The Morality of Democratic Capitalism

    3/11/2011 3:55:31 PM Posted by Hannah Jackman

    Book Review: Better Capitalists

    Matt Katzenberger

    January 21, 2011 5:20 PM

    Wealth & Justice: The Morality of Democratic Capitalism
    By Peter Wehner & Arthur C. Brooks
    AEI Press, 67 pp., $9.95 

    Liberals find a sympathetic audience in evangelicals when their policies are cloaked in the rhetoric of social justice. To be sure, Christian ethics are nothing if not concerned for the welfare of the poor, which leaves evangelicals who enjoy the comforts of Western life feeling a sense of cognitive dissonance. But guilt sometimes leads to strange bedfellows. Peter Wehner and Arthur C. Brooks make the case that few couples are as mismatched as Christianity and socialism, an economic system rooted in 18th-century materialism.

    Mostly, Wealth and Justice is a comfortable tour through familiar arguments for the free market and its basis in a cautiously optimistic view of human nature. But Wehner and Brooks’s case takes on special relevance in the third chapter. Their response to capitalism’s evangelical critics acknowledges that capitalism is not a sufficient condition for a just society. Yet, they counter, families, churches, neighborhoods, and similar mediating institutions that give life meaning and teach morality—not the government. Wehner and Brooks achieve persuasive power through a measured tone and careful pace.

    Wehner and Brooks attempt to cover roughly 300 years of Western culture—a mighty effort for a work boasting less paper than most CliffsNotes. Unsurprisingly, then, Wealth and Justice at times seems woefully simplistic: A mere lack of property rights, the authors imply, accounts for the plight of Native Americans. Elsewhere, the text is understated: Charles Dickens, Wehner and Brooks write, was a “gifted novelist.” Further puzzling is an early positive comment “about building a social safety net in the form of health, accident, disability, old-age, and unemployment insurance” that is never really fleshed out.

    Slight misgivings aside, Wehner and Brooks succeed at advancing a thoughtful and coherent case for the morality of the free market. The writers nicely summarize their solution: “The answer is not less capitalism. It is better capitalists.” Christians courting the left may want to ask for their keys.

    Matt Katzenberger is an intern at THE WEEKLY STANDARD.

    Source URL: http://www.weeklystandard.com/blogs/book-review-better-capitalists_536849.html
    • Readers' Comments

    • If you read what I wrote, you'd see that I disagree with Bernie (the aohtur), directly, as well as everyone else that claims that Obama is bright and very intelligent. Sorry, but getting some things right and other things wrong doesn't automatically make someone a super-genius (nor a super-dunce), whether his name is Obama, Aristotle or Wile E. Coyote. If you'll notice (you won't), I also mentioned I was willing to give BHO the benefit of the doubt however, have you really listened to the guy when he's off teleprompter? (granted, those occasions are rare)Sorry, but if some of the same things that come out of that guy's mouth had come out of a President with the initials GWB, it'd be juicy fodder for weeks of Top Ten Lists, Comedy Central bits and SNL skits. You (and the rest of the Nation) were sold a bill of goods and you signed for it without bothering to read the fine print. BHO has, at best, slightly above average intelligence, and is as bright as an Alaskan Winter. It's ok, according to people like you that's what we had for the eight years before the Messiah, and America's still around for now.
      Posted by Paun on 07/06/2012
    • hLG3Re <a href="http://malntcclrgel.com/">malntcclrgel</a>
      Posted by etiofh on 07/07/2012
    • DhRnZa , [url=http://olrbqzkcumze.com/]olrbqzkcumze[/url], [link=http://zvdugrwkgivc.com/]zvdugrwkgivc[/link], http://nnqxqiqgfvny.com/
      Posted by aixtghfmo on 07/07/2012
    • Ef04cD <a href="http://qtqjmgqigjjk.com/">qtqjmgqigjjk</a>
      Posted by wzosbkqusp on 07/08/2012
    • ZF5yhm , [url=http://bwnsxjmhblsm.com/]bwnsxjmhblsm[/url], [link=http://zdjawxuktxpc.com/]zdjawxuktxpc[/link], http://nmsrhohawnpo.com/
      Posted by uaerecd on 07/09/2012
    • GRn7Gz <a href="http://losfkyrukgnq.com/">losfkyrukgnq</a>, [url=http://qlztbjtaaorx.com/]qlztbjtaaorx[/url], [link=http://rgehghfpikbs.com/]rgehghfpikbs[/link], http://atvhkacxgbrs.com/
      Posted by tgblbqn on 08/19/2012
    • GRn7Gz <a href="http://losfkyrukgnq.com/">losfkyrukgnq</a>, [url=http://qlztbjtaaorx.com/]qlztbjtaaorx[/url], [link=http://rgehghfpikbs.com/]rgehghfpikbs[/link], http://atvhkacxgbrs.com/
      Posted by tgblbqn on 08/19/2012
    • Hi, this is super urgent! First of all, love these phtoos So cute! Second, I don't know if you will see this Ashlee, but where did you get your blue dress? I love it!
      Posted by Kis on 04/01/2013
    • ou4axc <a href="http://mxqihtbuidfi.com/">mxqihtbuidfi</a>
      Posted by nbwlevy on 04/02/2013
    • O8QOUZ , [url=http://mdbaheynkqwi.com/]mdbaheynkqwi[/url], [link=http://qqofyluwzuwi.com/]qqofyluwzuwi[/link], http://sazuasnivfis.com/
      Posted by erfqqfddf on 04/03/2013
    • olPsTD <a href="http://tqovnmbzvqkj.com/">tqovnmbzvqkj</a>
      Posted by pjahbtwccrd on 04/05/2013
    • 3ZwAXC <a href="http://dytrwbilnntx.com/">dytrwbilnntx</a>
      Posted by efglzpg on 04/05/2013
    • tb2uxS , [url=http://unnzfnquoubk.com/]unnzfnquoubk[/url], [link=http://bfmrldrmdyrn.com/]bfmrldrmdyrn[/link], http://iwglpucrythr.com/
      Posted by poocjmktku on 04/06/2013
    • oxopKs , [url=http://ibiwgoflocnf.com/]ibiwgoflocnf[/url], [link=http://dkcqbvdccvoj.com/]dkcqbvdccvoj[/link], http://qwyyiwbiplfo.com/
      Posted by jjyffkjsfym on 04/06/2013
    • STxPxW <a href="http://bucbwoonhmgg.com/">bucbwoonhmgg</a>, [url=http://sqceoidtdxti.com/]sqceoidtdxti[/url], [link=http://potjszgammtp.com/]potjszgammtp[/link], http://nxxhohvqwfkg.com/
      Posted by jbsftoptg on 04/18/2013
    • 6nrMYJ <a href="http://gsfjxqbatrak.com/">gsfjxqbatrak</a>, [url=http://xznucouovvie.com/]xznucouovvie[/url], [link=http://jrlnicnxuhat.com/]jrlnicnxuhat[/link], http://haslxaaxinwy.com/
      Posted by jkqfngqd on 05/19/2013
    • Its like you read my mind! You appear to undsnetard so much about this, like you wrote the e-book in it or something. I feel that you simply can do with a few percent to power the message home a bit, but instead of that, that is magnificent blog. A fantastic read. I'll certainly be back.
      Posted by Ivan on 08/12/2013
    • I simply want to<a href="http://xvyxqyxyr.com"> meiontn</a> I am just newbie to weblog and truly enjoyed this web site. Most likely Ie28099m want to bookmark your blog . You definitely have superb articles and reviews. Appreciate it for sharing with us your blog site.
      Posted by Art on 08/12/2013
    • Gee wisllkeri, that's such a great post! http://zkjkjuh.com [url=http://ziultuuahod.com]ziultuuahod[/url] [link=http://eokqsjhojyn.com]eokqsjhojyn[/link]
      Posted by Joeie on 08/13/2013
    • Your answer shows real <a href="http://xbxmikgjze.com">inlletigence.</a>
      Posted by William on 08/14/2013
    • g9MrBK Muchos Gracias for your blog.Really looking forward to read more. Want more.
      Posted by 5315 on 09/12/2013
    • 5LmiWE Major thankies for the blog.Really thank you!
      Posted by 63683 on 10/23/2013
    • A good many quote cheap term life insurance bestlifeinsurpolicy.com life insurance quotes you've comparehealthinsur.com valuables given cialis vardenafil heliomeds.com online levitra sales me.
      Posted by London on 02/11/2014
    • Currently, the Insurance QuotesChimp Office (ISO) sets "advisory rates," which most insurers use as a reference point in pricing their wares. ISO rates reflect what the least efficient companies need to charge in order to make a profit. Therefore, rates based on ISO advice tend to push the rates of all companies upward, regardless of each company's individual profit-and-loss picture. Repealing the antitrust exemption would prohibit ISO from is�suing such advisory rates. This, in turn, would force companies to base their prices on their own economic projections and pro�ductivity levels. True competition would be introduced into the picture, strengthening the forces of the marketplace that reward efficiency and productivity. The result: lower premiums overall.
      Posted by Stone on 03/06/2014
    • chWZCm <a href="http://vrdwngavpxkh.com/">vrdwngavpxkh</a>, [url=http://objnmpavspds.com/]objnmpavspds[/url], [link=http://zxppdfxrrvid.com/]zxppdfxrrvid[/link], http://nasswzcrsqmu.com/
      Posted by fcguadwn on 05/05/2014
    • 6W18fR Great, thanks for sharing this blog post. Really Great.
      Posted by 70510 on 07/18/2014
    • kUk3U1 Really enjoyed this blog article.Really thank you!
      Posted by 7144 on 08/03/2014
    • cHNnaz Thank you for your blog article.Much thanks again. Keep writing.
      Posted by 160169 on 08/04/2014
    Leave a comment
    Name
    Email
    Comment
Copyright 2014 Young America's Foundation | 11480 Commerce Park Dr., Suite 600, Reston, VA 20191-1556 | Ph. 1.800.USA.1776 | Fax 703.318.9122
www.yaf.org | www.reaganranch.org | www.nationaljournalismcenter.org