Young America's Foundation

Join Our Email List

  • New Guard Inner
  • YAFCONSTBy Becket Adams

    In a recent Think Magazine article titled “Club Funding Drops $175,000 Thanks Largely to YAF’s Lawsuit Threat,” the author Trevor Christian presents an unfair and incorrect narrative.

    Here are the facts: YAF was forced to consider legal action against Stony Brook University because they were denying them recognition as a legitimate group and not offering them the same funding that other student groups enjoy. The university was violating the First Amendment.

    Consider the Supreme Court in the Southworth case. Universities are an exception to the general rule that government cannot force one person to pay for another’s expression especially if one disagrees with it.  For example, in regards to union dues, the government cannot require public employees to pay the full union dues (including the amounts that go for political advocacy).

    However, universities are treated slightly different. YAF students can be required to pay into a student fee system that pays for a liberal group’s activities. The catch is that Stony Brook must have rules that ensure that money is distributed in a “viewpoint neutral manner” so that supporters of a leftist magazine would also be paying for YAF’s programs as well.

    But Stony Brook decided to stonewall YAF with a policy that permits student government to exclude new student groups from funding on the basis that their views are “too similar.” This is clearly not “viewpoint neutral.” It is also rather un-progressive. 

    On a side note, it is also inconsistent with the universities past practices. If the YAF chapter is denied funding because it is “too similar” to the College Republicans (as was the stated reason), then Stony Brook must explain how there are two separate student groups with extraordinarily similar mission statements.

    Stony Brook’s student group The Queer Alliance:

    “is a social and political group for queer students, particularly, but not exclusively graduate students and faculty.”

    Next, there is the LGBTA (Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transsexual, Alliance):

    “The Stony Brook LGBTA (Lesbian Gay Bisexual Transgender Alliance) is a campus group dedicated to promoting awareness of queer issues. By creating a more accepting and comfortable environment for queer students and their allies, the LGBTA hopes to foster diversity in the Stony Brook community.”

    Wouldn’t these two groups fall directly under the “too similar” rule?

    The conclusion that one naturally draws is that Think Magazine is actually more interested in protecting its own turf instead of actual “progress.”  Allowing the student government to examine the views of student groups and defund them on the basis that their views are subjectively “too similar” to another’s invites viewpoint discrimination. 

    Moreover, student government required new groups to get signed petitions from roughly 800 students supporting their funding – and requiring them to provide personal information.  Such a popularity contest is patently unconstitutional and even less problematic policies have been struck down elsewhere.  

    Stony Brook’s policies (and its actions in regards to YAF) clearly violated the First Amendment.  Yet, despite this, Stony Brook YAF did not immediately file a lawsuit.  Instead, it took the chance to correspond with the university and student government.  To their great credit, the university and student government recognized the constitutional problems in their policies and moved to correct them without any need for litigation.  As a result, all students’ rights are protected at Stony Brook. 

    Everyone should be pleased with this outcome.  Funding is distributed more equitably, the Constitutional rights of all students are respected, and litigation was not even necessary.  It is a win-win situation.

    YAF was not alone in this assessment. The university, the student government, and their attorneys also arrived at the same conclusion – hence the change in policy.  However, despite the clear consensus, Think Magazine describes the lawsuit “threat” as “ridiculous.”  Think Magazine just wants to have the leftist campus organizations to have their cake and eat YAF’s too. 

    Think Magazine does not do the former (Think) and is not really in favor of the latter (Progress). 

    Becket Adams is an intern at the National Journalism Center which is a project of Young Americas Foundation.

    • Readers' Comments

    • Your one example of other Stony Brook student groups with excessively similar mission statements is totally inaccurate. The LGBTA gets funding from the Undergraduate Student Government; the Queer Alliance does not and never has, and as a graduate student focused group would not be eligible for USG funding regardless of the other aspects of its mission statement.
      Posted by Elana on 07/02/2011
    • Think Magazine Fires Back: "YAF Hearts THiNK Magazine"
      Posted by Anonymous on 07/03/2011
    • KKLA Sports Apparel Co., Inc was established in 2000 in ZeJiang, China. Now it has 12 brnach companies around China. We are a worldwide wholesaler of Sports Apparel (Soccer Jersey,Football Jersey,baseball Jersey,Basketball Jersey,Icehockey Jersey). Our company consists of design, develop, produce, sale and service. Now we have more than 6 professional factories for our own products. Professional QC for professional products and service.You can mix NHL NBA Jerseysdifferent styles and sizes. And there is no mini order for you, Lowest price and Best service. Let's be friends and business partner. Don't hesitate to contact with us if you need anytime. We can supply those all NFL MLB NHL NBA Soccer Teams,such as NFL Teams: Baltimore Ravens Jersey ,Carolina Panthers Jersey , Green Bay Packers Jersey, Jacksonville Jaguars Jersey , New England Patriots Jersey,New Orleans Saints Jersey ,Philadelphia Eagles Jersey , Seattle Seahawks Jersey , Tennessee Titans Jersey ,NHL Teams : Buffalo Sabres Jersey , Colorado Avalanche Jersey ,Columbus Blue Jackets Jersey , Los Angeles Kings Jersey , New Jersey Devils Jersey , New York Rangers Jersey , Phoenix Coyotes Jersey , San Jose Sharks Jersey ,Tampa Bay Lightning Jersey , NBA Teams: Atlanta Hawks Jersey , Indiana Pacers Jersey, Memphis Grizzlies Jersey , New Jersey Nets Jersey , Oklahoma City Thunder Jersey , Portland Trail Blazers Jersey ,San Antonio Spurs Jersey ,Washington Wizards Jersey ,MLB Teams: Baltimore Orioles Jersey , Colorado Rockies Jersey , Kansas Royals Jersey, Minesota Twins Jersey, New York Yankees Jersey ,Pittsburgh Pirates Jersey , Texas Rangers Jersey,Tampa Bay Rays Jersey ,Soccer Teams: Chelsea Jersey, Juventus Jersey , Manchester City Jersey ,Red Bull Jersey , France Jersey , USA Jersey and so on
      Posted by Hmarova on 04/24/2013
    • 6n1h9u , [url=]eafuqosrkigg[/url], [link=]kvcqaepqckyo[/link],
      Posted by eflwkdri on 04/26/2013
    • 2fPx9T , [url=]pipohqnskwaj[/url], [link=]xtotgcsfdore[/link],
      Posted by ktcopnbhjr on 04/29/2013
    • jdOiqL , [url=]srvhczxjsosd[/url], [link=]fsunjbjbxuha[/link],
      Posted by uwmqbzbuac on 04/29/2013
    • YHaKyb , [url=]qfmoqyfxxrpm[/url], [link=]ambjstyvscfu[/link],
      Posted by coeuxq on 04/29/2013
    • 4qZugF Very neat post.Much thanks again. Want more.
      Posted by 299849 on 09/05/2013
    • cLbZsR wow, awesome blog article.Thanks Again. Fantastic.
      Posted by 2280 on 09/12/2013
    • gx4tGL Im grateful for the blog post.Really looking forward to read more. Really Great.
      Posted by 259522 on 10/15/2013
    • BQeeQp Thanks again for the article.Thanks Again. Really Cool.
      Posted by 585930 on 10/26/2013
    • M8NpGt Thanks again for the blog article.Really looking forward to read more. Much obliged.
      Posted by 927871 on 04/19/2014
    • RzAhgE I really like and appreciate your blog post.Much thanks again.
      Posted by 954762 on 05/11/2014
    • TfR1iU Thanks for the article.Thanks Again.
      Posted by 82372 on 06/19/2014
    • ABpkHY A round of applause for your blog post.Thanks Again. Will read on...
      Posted by 883445 on 07/18/2014
    Leave a comment
Copyright 2014 Young America's Foundation | 11480 Commerce Park Dr., Suite 600, Reston, VA 20191-1556 | Ph. 1.800.USA.1776 | Fax 703.318.9122 | |