Young America's Foundation

Join Our Email List

  • cliches23

    Click here to read published commentary

    The More Complex the Society, the More Government Control We Need

    by Leonard E. Read

    governmentcontrolArgued a college president at a recent seminar: "Your free market, private property, limited government theories were all right under the simple conditions of a century or more ago, but surely they are unworkable in today's complex economy. The more complex the society, the greater is the need for governmental control; that seems axiomatic."

    It is important to expose this oft-heard, plausible, and influential fallacy because it leads directly and logically to socialistic planning. This is how a member of the seminar team answered the college president:

    "Let us take the simplest possible situation-just you and I. Next, let us assume that I am as wise as any President of the United States who has held office during your lifetime. With these qualifications in mind, do you honestly think I would be competent to coercively control what you shall invent discover, or create, what the hours of your labor shall be, what wage you shall receive, what and with whom you shall associate and exchange? Is not my incompetence demonstrably apparent in this simplest of all societies?

    "Now, let us shift from the simple situation to a more complex society-to all the people in this room. What would you think of my competence to coercively control their creative actions? Or, let us contemplate a really complex situation-the 188,000,000 people of this nation (Editor's note: now, in 2014, about 318 million). If I were to suggest that I should suggest that I should take over the management of their lives and their billions of exchanges, you would think me the victim of hallucinations. Is it not obvious that the more complex an economy, the more certainly will governmental control of productive effort exert a retarding influence? Obviously, the more complex our economy, the more we should rely on the miraculous, self-adapting processes of men acting freely. No mind of man nor any combination of minds can even envision, let alone intelligently control, the countless human energy exchanges in a simple society, to say nothing of a complex one."

    It is unlikely that the college president will raise that question again.

    While exposing fallacies can be likened to beating out brush fires endlessly, the exercise is nonetheless self-improving as well as useful-in the sense that rear guard actions are useful. Further, one's ability to expose fallacies-a negative tactic-appears to be a necessary preface to influentially accenting the positive. Unless a person can demonstrate competence at exploding socialistic error, he is not likely to gain wide audiences for his views about the wonders wrought by men who are free.

    Of all the errors heard in classrooms or elsewhere, there is not one that cannot be simply explained away. We only need to put our minds to it. The Foundation for Economic Education seeks to help those who would expose fallacies and accent the merits of freedom. The more who outdo us in rendering this kind of help, the better.

     

    Leonard E. Read

    Founder and President of FEE, 1946-1983

     

     

    Summary

     

     

    Editor's Note

     

    This was the first chapter in the first edition of Clichés of Socialism when it appeared in 1962. Though the "complexity requires control" fallacy is not publicly expressed so boldly today, it is still implicit in the core assumptions of modern Progressivism. Almost every new innovation gives rise to some call from some Progressive somewhere to regulate it, monitor it, sometimes even ban it. Rarely will a Progressive reject new assignments for government, even though it has already assumed so many that it manages so poorly (and at a financial loss). It behooves us to point out that the more government attempts to control, the less well it will perform all of its duties, including the essential ones. Leonard Read passed away in 1983 but his wisdom as expressed here still resonates.

Copyright 2013 Young America's Foundation | 110 Elden Street, Herndon, VA 20170 | Ph. 1.800.USA.1776 | Fax 703.318.9122
www.yaf.org | www.reaganranch.org | www.nationaljournalismcenter.org