Young America's Foundation

Join Our Email List

  • New Guard Inner
  • It's Not Us, It's You

    10/31/2012 10:50:27 AM Posted by Patrick Coyle

     ClassroomBy Stephen Smoot 

    It’s not us, it’s you.

    This paraphrases the basic theme of the latest in a series of studies by Clemson University’s Darren Linvill and Joseph Mazer.  In short, left wing bias does not come from academic leftists, but from students too unskilled to take on faculty in debate.

    According to an article scheduled to be published in Communication Education next January, Linvill and Mazer argue that if students came to college with better argumentation skills, they would be less likely to see professors as biased.  Also it claims that students who enjoy arguments will defend their beliefs in class more often and be less likely to hide their ideals.

    This mimics the results of a study published in College Teaching in 2011 by, again, Darren Linvill.  It also attacked the ability of college students to perceive or understand left wing bias in their college classrooms.

    In other words, when West Virginia University engineering student Michael Boggs says “college campuses are liberal and I doubt they are ever going to change,” the study will not say that he bases his perception on reasonable experience.   It will claim that the 24 year old Iraq War veteran has not yet learned to argue effectively.

    Some of the methods behind the study remain open to question.  Linvill and Mazer surveyed 45 freshmen, 65 sophomores, 84 juniors, but questioned only 32 seniors and no graduate students.  It omitted the most articulate students who could best discuss left wing bias. 

    Linvill’s studies examine the individual tree to generalize about the whole forest.  Classroom interactions are important.  Bias, however, expresses itself in a number of ways.  Why does one college’s “Festival of Ideas” series of speakers promise a diversity of viewpoints, but only offer liberals from a variety of fields?  Why do, as University of Dayton professor Larry Schweikart describes, so many textbooks attack the notion that America is exceptional, or even special?  Why do course offerings seem to so heavily favor the liberal and left agendas, while conservatives get attacked or ignored?

    What about the plain fact that absolute monarchs rarely held the power enjoyed by a tenured professor within his or her classroom?  Professors must take great pains to reassure students that open debate is encouraged because of the very nature of their powerful role.

    Studies from liberal academics that say there is little or no liberal bias are useless.  Conservative activists should understand that liberal professors will use studies like this to fight accusations of bias.

    Amazingly, the same liberals who blast “blame the victim” studies in research on poverty or discrimination seem to embrace the idea when conservatives face discrimination. 

    Bias can take many forms.  Sometimes it is intentional.  Course offerings, personnel hiring, etc. can be guided by an agenda.  In other cases, it comes from groupthink.  Enough individuals of like minds come together and see their worldview as the only rational one.  Bernard Goldberg described this process in Bias.  Although the book is about the media, the same factors affect the academic world.  Goldberg quotes a Peter Jennings statement from 2001 that sounds eerily similar to Linvill’s conclusions.  “I think bias is very largely in the eye of the beholder.”

    In other words, many of America’s college campuses and their professionals have no idea that they are biased.  Even more than the media, many operate in their own worldview, almost completely shut off from true engagement with the world.

    The schoolyard bully cannot defend him or herself by saying that the other kids should learn to fistfight better.  Just in the last week a college instructor’s liberal bias discrimination suit went to trial. The plaintiff in the case produced emails from other professionals who warned her to hide her beliefs. Would Linvill argue that graduate students and untenured professors who hide their values are also unskilled in argument? Or has an atmosphere of intolerance set in at many of our institutions of higher learning? 

    Colleges and universities need to understand that true diversity comes from bringing together and respecting a wide variety of backgrounds and ideals.  Only then can even handed debates on important issues begin. 

    Stephen Smoot is the Director of Academic Programs at the National Journalism Center.

     

    • Readers' Comments

    • SQJ3nz <a href="http://couurhyeaxap.com/">couurhyeaxap</a>, [url=http://ofggiipliybr.com/]ofggiipliybr[/url], [link=http://ykuamxblqqnl.com/]ykuamxblqqnl[/link], http://kjogxsjbgzwe.com/
      Posted by pivpkdducu on 11/28/2012
    • VFz5ZE Major thanks for the blog.Really thank you!
      Posted by 285059 on 09/13/2013
    • PdMkUV Im thankful for the post.Really looking forward to read more. Will read on...
      Posted by 53289 on 09/24/2013
    • JaQzpK Enjoyed every bit of your post.Really looking forward to read more. Great.
      Posted by 293613 on 10/15/2013
    • NcDoqY A round of applause for your blog.Really looking forward to read more. Great.
      Posted by 2348 on 10/15/2013
    • I32IkY Major thanks for the post.Much thanks again. Really Great.
      Posted by 8476 on 11/18/2013
    • NnIwJN Very informative blog post.Really looking forward to read more. Really Cool.
      Posted by 96446 on 12/15/2013
    • cUaTGP I loved your blog article.Really thank you! Great.
      Posted by 32120 on 01/07/2014
    • CkZ1ZQ Appreciate you sharing, great blog post. Much obliged.
      Posted by 936792 on 01/17/2014
    • nYdF1S Appreciate you sharing, great blog.Really looking forward to read more. Really Great.
      Posted by 953921 on 01/30/2014
    • NCnGlR I really enjoy the post.Really thank you! Fantastic.
      Posted by 282406 on 02/28/2014
    • UovvBQ I really like and appreciate your blog.Thanks Again. Want more.
      Posted by 264702 on 03/22/2014
    • OVG9dF I really like and appreciate your article. Keep writing.
      Posted by 4385 on 04/01/2014
    • AGpxUa Thanks-a-mundo for the article.Thanks Again. Great.
      Posted by 55910 on 04/18/2014
    Leave a comment
    Name
    Email
    Comment
Copyright 2013 Young America's Foundation | 110 Elden Street, Herndon, VA 20170 | Ph. 1.800.USA.1776 | Fax 703.318.9122
www.yaf.org | www.reaganranch.org | www.nationaljournalismcenter.org